Musnad Ahmad 6929 Verified -
No. According to Sunni theology, being the "transgressing group" ( al-fi'ah al-baghiyah ) does not equate to committing disbelief ( kufr ). It means they were in error in their action (killing Ammar), but they were still considered believers and companions.
by major scholars due to its wide transmission through numerous independent chains. Ḥadīth Unlocked Key Content of Hadith 6929
In the English translation of Musnad Ahmad (Darussalam, 2012 edition), the researchers graded Hadith 6929 as (Good).
: The hadith describes a scene where two men approached Mu'awiyah during the Battle of Siffin, both claiming to have killed Ammar ibn Yasir . musnad ahmad 6929 verified
Because Ammar was killed while fighting on the side of Ali ibn Abi Talib , this hadith is often cited by scholars to affirm that Ali's side was closer to the truth, while the opposing group was "rebellious" in the technical legal sense (without necessarily implying they left the fold of Islam).
This is a famous and concise hadith that carries immense hope for the believers.
is a verified prophetic narration that addresses a pivotal historical event in early Islamic history: the martyrdom of Ammar ibn Yasir and the religious weight of parental obedience . by major scholars due to its wide transmission
A master memorizer. Ibn Hajar said: Thiqah, Thabit (Trustworthy and firm). Reliable.
A tabi’i known for extreme precision and piety. Consensus on his reliability. Reliable.
: Ammar ibn Yasir was an iconic elderly companion who was among the very first converts to Islam. The Prophet Muhammad had explicitly loved him and made multiple statements regarding his righteousness. Because Ammar was killed while fighting on the
(in the common numbering of the Cairo edition) is an authentic hadith about the four qualities that guarantee success in the Hereafter if one possesses them, even if they miss out on worldly gains. 📜 The Text of the Hadith The Prophet ﷺ said:
The following post provides the text, translation, and verification status for , a significant narration concerning the martyrdom of Ammar bin Yasir and the "rebellious group." 📜 Hadith Information Source: Musnad Ahmad Hadith Number: 6929
Historical commentaries note that when Mu'awiya was confronted with this hadith after Ammar's death, he famously reinterpreted it by claiming, "We did not kill him; those who brought him here [to the battlefield] killed him". Significance of Ammar:
If you are looking for a of the chain of narrators , or want to know how other hadith scholars (like al-Bukhari) narrate this incident, I can provide that. Aḥmad (أحمد) ahmad:6929 - Ḥadīth Unlocked
: Verified parallel tracks of this text in his evaluation of Abu Dawud and graded the core ruling as authentic. 4. Why Text Numbering Varies