The story revolves around Aditya Sharma (played by Vikrant Massey), a cab driver who picks up a mysterious passenger, Sanjana Saxena. After a night of partying, drug consumption, and sexual intimacy, Aditya wakes up in his cab to find Sanjana brutally murdered in the back seat.
In the climax of Disney+ Hotstar's Criminal Justice Season 1, the real killer of Sanaya Rath is revealed to be , the wife of influential businessman Naresh Lakhani.
Before her death, Sanaya had been working at the (a counseling and rehabilitation center for mentally disturbed youths). This foundation was run by Naresh Lakhani , a close family friend of Sanaya’s stepfather. While the public viewed the LFRDC as a noble, charitable organization treating children free of cost, Sanaya discovered its dark reality.
In Episode 5, Mrs. Pemberton hires a private investigator. They discover that Debbie had recently broken up with a man named , a tall, dark-haired stranger she met at a pub. Gary had a history of violence and had been stalking her.
If you want to dive deeper into this series, let me know if you would like me to: who was the killer in criminal justice season 1
When Ben wakes up hours later, the nightmare begins. He goes upstairs to find Melanie stabbed to death in her bed. Panicking, Ben flees the scene, cleans the knife, and accidentally crashes the taxi. He is arrested under heavy suspicion, carrying the murder weapon in his pocket, with absolutely no memory of the killing due to the substance blackout. The False Leads and the Defense
Mandira managed to prove that the sexual encounter was consensual, dropping the rape charge but failing to secure an immediate acquittal for the murder.
Aditya Sharma was ultimately cleared of the murder charges, but the trauma of the investigation, jail time, and the loss of his old life left him fundamentally changed, highlighting the show's theme of the emotional and personal cost of the justice system.
Kanika Lakhani discovered that Sanaya, who was on the verge of divulging this information to the public, knew about her husband's illicit activities. To protect her family, her social standing, and her husband's criminal empire from being exposed, . With the help of her husband's influence, she orchestrated the crime scene to frame Aditya, who had been with Sanaya that night, as the perfect scapegoat. The story revolves around Aditya Sharma (played by
Because Ben cannot remember the events of the night, he is eventually found guilty of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment.
To understand the killer’s identity, we must first look at the night of the crime. Ben Coulter, a young, mild-mannered man, takes his father's taxi for an unauthorized joyride. He meets Melanie Lloyd, a mysterious and alluring young woman.
The motive for the murder is deeply sinister. Madhav Mishra's investigation discovers that Sanaya had stumbled upon a dark secret. Dr. Naresh Lakhani was not merely a doctor; he was running a child and sex trafficking racket from his rehabilitation centre, preying on underprivileged children.
Melanie was entangled with much more dangerous people than a panicked young student. Before her death, Sanaya had been working at
To prevent the exposure of this lucrative, illegal business, Naresh Lakhani and his wife conspired to eliminate her. It was eventually established that Naresh Lakhani's wife was directly involved in the murder. How the Killer Was Uncovered
When Naresh Lakhani’s wife, , realized that Sanaya possessed information that could permanently destroy their family, fortune, and freedom, she decided to take lethal action.
, the victim's financial advisor, who had a history of violence and was stalking her.